In the early morning of October 6, 2024, Trump delivered his victory speech. (Photo by Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)
[People News] The latest informal meeting of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC) leaders took place on November 19 in Shenzhen, China. U.S. President Trump arrived on the afternoon of the 18th and held bilateral meetings with Russian President Putin and Chinese Communist Party leader Xi Jinping the next day. The three leaders also conducted their first trilateral meeting, which garnered more attention than the summit itself, with extensive coverage from Chinese media.
The Chinese Communist Party was the first to issue a joint statement from the three heads of state. The statement began by noting that "the Russian and American leaders expressed gratitude to the Chinese side for hosting this historic meeting," and emphasised that "the three heads of state engaged in an in-depth exchange of views on the current international situation and are committed to maintaining strategic stability and international security."
The statement outlined four key points: First, as permanent members of the United Nations Security Council, the three countries "are dedicated to promoting UN reform... and fulfilling their essential mission of maintaining international peace and security." Second, they "plan to increase the production and supply of refined oil products" and "reaffirm the importance of stable energy flows." Third, they "unanimously agree that the International Criminal Court and other similar institutions should not abuse their jurisdiction." Fourth, they "reaffirm that nuclear war cannot be won and must not be fought. The three countries will engage in dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and prevent nuclear proliferation."
Firstly, there are notable differences between the U.S. and China regarding the push for United Nations reform. Following Trump's return to the White House, the United States announced its withdrawal from several organisations, including the United Nations Human Rights Council and the World Health Organisation, and significantly cut funding to various international organisations. This decision stems from the perception that the UN has been deeply infiltrated by the Chinese Communist Party (CCP). Despite being the largest financial contributor to the UN, the U.S. has found itself in a position where the UN serves as a tool for the CCP's anti-American agenda, a reality that Trump is acutely aware of.
As a result, the U.S. has set conditions for its dues payments, demanding reforms in nine specific areas within the UN. These reforms include changes to the UN pension system, ending business-class travel for certain senior officials and all mid-level officials, reducing the number of senior official positions, and preventing China from contributing to a discretionary fund managed by the UN Secretary-General's office each year. In essence, not only must the UN reform itself, but it must also restrict the CCP's funding and influence.
The critical question is whether the CCP is willing to cease its infiltration of the UN and the U.S. to achieve its goal of destabilising the U.S. from within. The answer is clearly no. The CCP is simply engaging in its usual tactic of 'saying one thing and doing another.'
Secondly, regarding stable energy flows, the U.S., as a leading global exporter of oil and natural gas, relies on China's vast market to absorb its products. Trump hopes that the CCP will increase its purchases of American oil and gas while also encouraging China and Russia to exert influence over Iran to prevent disruptions in the energy market.
China and Russia's agreement on this matter can be seen as a minor success from Trump's meetings. However, for the CCP, which excels at the art of 'saying one thing and doing another,' mere agreement does not guarantee action.
Third, it is not surprising that the leaders of the three countries reached a consensus on the principle that 'the International Criminal Court and other similar institutions must not abuse their jurisdiction.' Neither the United States nor China is a signatory to the Rome Statute. Trump has consistently criticised the International Criminal Court for its long-arm jurisdiction over American citizens, while the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) opposes the exercise of jurisdiction over nationals of non-signatory countries. They are particularly concerned that the situation in 2023, when an arrest warrant was issued for Putin by the International Court, could similarly occur with CCP leaders. In the author's opinion, this point may be the only one among the four that received sincere agreement from all three leaders.
Regarding the dangers of nuclear war, the three leaders also found common ground. However, the statement that 'the three countries will engage in dialogue to reduce nuclear risks and prevent nuclear proliferation' suggests that Trump did not achieve his intended objectives. Prior to the summit, Trump had indicated a desire to discuss nuclear weapons control.
On February 5 of this year, the New START treaty between the U.S. and Russia expired after five years, mainly because the Trump administration declined to renew it. Previously, Trump had responded to questions about renewal by stating, 'It expires, it expires.' He also expressed hope for a 'more favourable' agreement that would include China. This implies that the United States does not wish to be constrained by this treaty while the CCP, viewed as the primary 'enemy,' can develop nuclear weapons without such limitations.
On November 2, just ahead of the summit, the American journal 'Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists' published a new research analysis by Harvard University nuclear expert Zhang Hui, highlighting that the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) is significantly expanding its uranium enrichment facilities in Emei Mountain, Sichuan. Notably, the Emei Mountain base has not been included in the verification scope of the International Atomic Energy Agency. What is the CCP's motive behind accelerating its nuclear weapons development? The CCP's agreement to engage in 'dialogue' regarding nuclear arms control appears to be merely a superficial tactic.
In summary, while the declaration from the three heads of state seems to have reached four points of consensus, the actual outcomes are quite limited. If the Trump team takes this seriously, they may have fallen into the CCP's trap. Any commitments made by the CCP should not be taken at face value; one must listen to their words and observe their actions closely.
In addition to the trilateral meeting, Trump also held separate discussions with Putin and Xi Jinping. The meeting between Trump and Putin lasted approximately 48 minutes. According to reports from the Russian news agency, Putin's assistant Ushakov informed the media that Putin was in a very good mood following his meeting with Trump.
The American delegation included Secretary of State Rubio and Treasury Secretary Basant. The Russian delegation comprised Foreign Minister Lavrov, Presidential Assistant Ushakov, Finance Minister Siluanov, and Dmitriev, the president of the Russian Direct Investment Fund and special representative of the president for foreign investment and economic cooperation. Reports also noted that after the meeting, Putin acknowledged Rubio and Basant, who were present at the talks.
What kind of meeting could leave Putin in such high spirits? It is evident that, aside from discussing the Russia-Ukraine war, both parties also addressed economic investment cooperation, which likely contributed to Putin's positive mood.
Let’s take another look at the meeting between Trump and Xi Jinping. According to the press release from the Chinese Communist Party's official media, it appears that the two leaders were still talking past each other. Xi called for the development of China-U.S. relations based on the principles of 'respect, fairness, and equality,' but Trump dismissed this, fully aware that the fundamental logic of both sides is entirely different. The CCP's so-called principles allow Chinese enterprises and agents to operate freely and without restrictions in the U.S., while American businesses and media personnel face regulation and suppression by the CCP in China.
Xi remarked that 'on the Taiwan issue, the U.S. must insist on doing the right thing to avoid major setbacks in China-U.S. relations,' while Trump simply reiterated his previous position of 'not supporting Taiwan independence,' rather than the 'opposing Taiwan independence' that the CCP seeks.
When discussing economic and trade relations, Xi stated, 'We need to strengthen communication, address each other's concerns, and strive for mutual benefit and reciprocity.' Trump responded that 'the trade and investment relationship between the two countries is continuously strengthening,' expressing hope to 'enhance cooperation in areas such as agricultural products, energy, and superintelligence, and fairly address each other's concerns.' This indicates that Trump wants Xi to fulfil his commitment to purchase American products, but Xi did not respond.
In areas where progress has been made, Trump noted that both sides have achieved results in 'cooperation in areas such as fentanyl,' while Xi claimed that 'the cooperation between the two countries in drug control, illegal immigration repatriation, and combating telecom network fraud has been effective, and can continue to strengthen based on the principles of respect, fairness, and equality.' Xi did not specifically mention fentanyl, which poses a threat to the U.S., but instead categorised it as a drug, clearly downplaying its serious harmful effects.
In relation to artificial intelligence, Trump did not address the current media spotlight on Jensen Huang of NVIDIA aiding the Chinese Communist Party in obtaining high-end chips. Instead, he merely noted that both parties are enhancing cooperation in this area. Xi emphasised that both sides are improving communication to 'prevent security risks associated with artificial intelligence and ensure that it remains under human control.'
It can be said that the Trump-Xi meeting was simply another opportunity for both sides to maintain a superficial relationship, yet their differences remain unresolved.
Among the three meetings Trump held in Shenzhen, the discussions with Putin might be the only ones that had any real impact. The other two meetings appeared to be more about formality than substance.
Nonetheless, it is undeniable that this first trilateral meeting involving Trump can be leveraged by the Chinese Communist Party and Xi as a point of pride, both on the global stage and domestically, and can also bolster the CCP's narrative regarding the legitimacy of its governance. From this standpoint, the setbacks Trump faced during this trip are quite considerable.
(Originally published by People News) △

News magazine bootstrap themes!
I like this themes, fast loading and look profesional
Thank you Carlos!
You're welcome!
Please support me with give positive rating!
Yes Sure!