The Film and Television Industry Is Currently Facing a Storm Over AI Face Theft, as Actress Zhao Liying Has Filed a Lawsuit Against Hongguo!

The film and television industry is currently facing a storm over AI face theft, as actress Zhao Liying has filed a lawsuit against Hongguo! (Video)

[People News] Renowned Chinese actress Zhao Liying has recently taken legal action against the short drama Hongguo!

The reason behind this lawsuit is quite shocking. It is alleged that someone used AI technology to superimpose her face onto characters in the short drama without her consent, creating the illusion that a person who is not Zhao Liying is performing as her.

Zhao Liying is furious and has sued Hongguo for stealing the faces of stars!

On November 10, the People's Court of Mentougou District in Beijing held a hearing regarding this portrait rights dispute.

The defendants in this case include not only the operating company of the Hongguo short drama, Beijing Bimo Liuxiang Technology Co., Ltd., but also its wholly-owned shareholder, Beijing Douyin Information Service Co., Ltd., along with an individual named Shi.

In this instance, Zhao Liying is not only pursuing those who allegedly used her likeness but has also brought related companies of the short drama platform into the lawsuit. The case is still pending judgment.

Previously, stealing a celebrity's likeness might have involved secretly using a photo for advertising purposes. However, the situation has changed. AI can now not only replicate a face but also animate that face to cry, laugh, speak, and even perform an entire short drama.

Furthermore, producers do not need to hire Zhao Liying, pay her fees, or even seek her consent.

For some viewers, the more convincingly AI imitates a face, the more intriguing it becomes. Even when they know it might not be a real person performing, they still feel compelled to watch. However, for actors, this situation is far from amusing.

I have never taken on this role or seen the script, yet I suddenly found another 'myself' online, acting for others, attracting an audience, and even generating revenue for others.

What if this AI character performs inappropriate scenes or makes unsuitable remarks, and the audience connects this character with the real person? Wouldn't the image that the actor has cultivated over the years be at risk of being damaged?

However, Zhao Liying's lawsuit has ignited a different kind of debate.

Some argue that since the AI-generated character does not directly use Zhao Liying's photo and is a computer-generated figure, why shouldn't it be allowed?

But following this logic, as long as you make slight adjustments to the star's eyes and nose while keeping the overall familiar look, can you freely use it for filming, marketing, and profit?

Article 1019 of China's Civil Code explicitly states that one must not use information technology to infringe upon another's portrait rights through forgery or other means.

You Yunting, a lawyer at Shanghai Dabang Law Firm, noted in an interview with The Paper that whether an AI-generated face infringes on rights is not about whether it is 100% identical to a real person, but whether the general public can recognise it.

In other words, if people can easily identify that this face is mimicking Zhao Liying, then even if it is AI-generated, it could still involve a violation of portrait rights.

Yet, there is an even more pressing issue in this lawsuit.

If a short drama production team uses AI to imitate Zhao Liying today, Yang Mi tomorrow, and other stars the day after, uploading these works to platforms and attracting a large audience, what will happen when the stars notice and raise objections? Will the platform simply take down the videos?

So, what should be done about the traffic and revenue already generated before the video was taken down? Furthermore, can the platform truly shift all responsibility onto the short drama producers?

In April of this year, Hongguo Short Drama found itself in controversy due to another production, "Peach Blossom Hairpin," which was suspected of AI face-swapping infringement. After receiving complaints, the platform requested the production company to provide proof of legal use of the materials.

Ultimately, the production company was unable to provide sufficient evidence, leading the platform to take down the work and suspend the production company from uploading episodes for 15 days. This highlights that the issue of AI "face theft" is not a new phenomenon.

Now, Zhao Liying has taken legal action against the relevant company of the platform, effectively bringing this issue to the judicial level.

A star's face embodies the recognition and commercial value built over years of their acting career.

Now, others can create an AI-generated version of her that audiences can recognise without needing to hire her for acting or pay her fees. If even a prominent and resourceful actress like Zhao Liying must resort to legal action to protect her likeness, what options do lesser-known actors, who cannot afford legal representation, have?

Even more troubling is that those being "recast" by AI now include actors who have been deceased for many years.

AI has even resurrected Lin Daiyu! Have 17 actors from "Dream of the Red Chamber" fallen victim to face theft?

In the 1987 version of "Dream of the Red Chamber," Chen Xiaoxu's portrayal of Lin Daiyu remains an irreplaceable classic in the hearts of many viewers.

Recently, there has been a surprising development in which AI technology has been used to resurrect the late Chen Xiaoxu, who passed away 19 years ago, allowing her to "reappear" in a short drama that reimagines "Dream of the Red Chamber" as a revenge story!

It is astonishing that an actress who has been gone for nearly two decades is featured in a newly produced short drama!

In this production, she reprises her iconic role as Lin Daiyu. The AI short drama, titled "Dream Back to the Red Chamber," has ignited significant controversy across Chinese social media.

The portrayal of Lin Daiyu in the drama bears a striking resemblance to Chen Xiaoxu's character from the 1987 adaptation of "Dream of the Red Chamber." Additionally, characters such as Wang Xifeng and Xue Baochai have been recreated using AI to resemble the original actors. This short drama features the likenesses of 17 cast members from the original series.

The 1987 version of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is considered a classic in Chinese television history. The performances of Lin Daiyu by Chen Xiaoxu, Xue Baochai by Zhang Li, and Wang Xifeng by Deng Jie have remained etched in the memories of viewers for decades.

Particularly, Chen Xiaoxu's legacy is profound. She passed away on May 13, 2007, at the age of just 41. Now, 19 years later, AI technology has made it possible for her familiar face to grace the screen once again, even allowing her to portray a completely different interpretation of Lin Daiyu as envisioned by the producers.

What is even more difficult for audiences to accept is the storyline of this short drama. The sensitive and talented Lin Daiyu from the original narrative has been reimagined as a vengeful protagonist in the AI adaptation!

According to plot summaries circulating online, Lin Daiyu is no longer the melancholic girl lamenting her love and fate; instead, she returns with memories from her past life to exact revenge.

She aims to take revenge on Xue Baochai and confront the members of the Jia family, transforming the entire narrative into a drama rife with schemes, vengeance, and conflict.

Is this still Cao Xueqin's "Dream of the Red Chamber"? Some netizens found it unbearable and directly exclaimed: Stop mistreating your grandfather Cao Xueqin! While this remark is tinged with sarcasm, it highlights the frustration of many viewers regarding the casual alterations made to classic literature.

The crux of this controversy lies in the fact that the producers not only adapted the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber" but also allegedly appropriated the likenesses of actors from the 1987 adaptation.

The actors themselves did not participate and may not have consented to this use, yet AI technology enables their likenesses to be used in performances based on a new script. For living actors, this raises significant issues concerning portrait rights and authorisation.

As for the late Chen Xiaoxu, she cannot possibly come forward to express whether she consents to being reimagined by AI as a vengeful female lead.

Article 994 of China's Civil Code protects the personal interests of deceased individuals, including their names, images, and reputations, allowing eligible close relatives to pursue legal action for infringement.

Following the controversy, this AI short drama was removed around November 12. With the work taken down, does that mean the issue is resolved?

As previously mentioned, AI can not only replicate the appearances of celebrities but also allow deceased actors to "reappear" in short dramas. So, can AI truly replace live actors? And what concerning issues is this technology generating?

Celebrities are being impersonated by AI for commercial purposes! With fake faces and voices—who is actually profiting?

AI has evolved to the point where it not only allows celebrities to 'shoot films' without their involvement but can also enable them to live-stream and promote products without their knowledge.

In early November, actress Wu Yue publicly expressed her outrage over the misuse of AI technology to impersonate her image in fake promotional videos.

Similarly, actress Wen Zhengrong revealed that someone had used AI to create her likeness for live-stream sales. Upon discovering this, she entered the live stream to confront them, only to find herself blocked by the other party.

Previously, businesses seeking celebrity endorsements had to negotiate contracts and pay endorsement fees. Now, some can simply use a set of AI tools to feature a celebrity's face and voice in advertisements.

Consumers, seeing familiar faces and hearing recognisable voices, might mistakenly believe that the celebrity is personally endorsing the product, leading them to confidently place orders. By the time they realise they've been deceived, the products may have already been sold, and the money collected.

However, some celebrities do authorise businesses or platforms to use their likeness, voice, and even create AI digital avatars for advertisements, live-stream sales, or appearances in games.

These legitimate commercial collaborations are fundamentally different from the unauthorised use of celebrity images. Yet, for the average viewer, this is where the confusion arises.

When we open our phones and see a familiar celebrity recommending a product, how can we discern whether it is an AI avatar authorised by the celebrity or a counterfeit created without permission?

Just by looking at the face or even listening to the voice, it may be impossible to tell the difference.

If platforms do not clearly label their content, how can consumers discern whether they are witnessing a genuine celebrity endorsement or a carefully crafted AI impersonation promoting products?

Furthermore, the potential dangers escalate if this technology is used to impersonate ordinary individuals. With just a person's photo and voice, AI can synthesise videos or audio to impersonate friends or family, soliciting help or requesting money transfers, and even creating fake video calls. Thus, this issue extends beyond the portrait rights of celebrities; it poses a direct threat to the financial security of everyday people.

As AI begins to permeate film and television production on a large scale, the repercussions are not confined to celebrity portrait rights. In Hengdian, China's largest film and television production hub, many real actors are confronting a different challenge: with no roles available, they face unemployment and decreasing incomes. Will AI truly replace actors entirely in the future?

Can AI take the place of real actors? The Chinese film and television industry is undergoing a significant transformation!

If a short drama features only attractive AI characters but has a monotonous plot, stiff expressions, and lacks engaging storytelling, viewers may quickly lose interest after just a few minutes.

In fact, the emergence of AI short dramas does not diminish the value of real actors.

Exceptional actors bring more to the table than just good looks. A glance, a pause, or the emotion conveyed in a line of dialogue is often a crucial factors that keep viewers engaged.

While AI can replicate a face and generate a crying scene, its ability to genuinely move an audience ultimately hinges on the quality of the work itself.

As a result, the Chinese film and television industry is likely to experience significant changes in the future. Many low-cost, repetitive production tasks will increasingly be assigned to AI; however, creative screenwriters, directors, and actors will still hold their own value.

The pressing question is whether grassroots actors and behind-the-scenes workers, who are already facing hardships, can find new pathways during this transition.

On one hand, live actors are struggling to find roles, leaving studios empty; on the other hand, AI actors are being produced continuously, with AI short dramas being released one after another. What the Chinese film and television industry truly lacks are compelling stories that can motivate audiences to spend money and time watching.

In a country like China, where counterfeit products are widespread and fake advertisements are common, even the faces, voices, and performances of stars in movies and short dramas can now be generated by AI.

What is particularly thought-provoking is that, despite knowing that some characters are fictional and some stars never actually appeared, so many people are still willing to watch. This phenomenon has even turned these AI short dramas into a new business model for generating traffic.

As AI technology continues to advance, will there come a day when most of China's future films and TV dramas are produced by AI, while works featuring live actors become increasingly rare, perhaps even regarded as a unique form of art?

If that day arrives, would you be able to accept it? Would you prefer to watch movies and short dramas featuring AI actors, or do you still prefer live actors with real emotions? We invite you to share your opinions in the comments section.

If you enjoyed today's program, please remember to like, subscribe, and feel free to share it, so that more friends can join the discussion.

Thank you for tuning in to 'Forbidden News Decoded'. We look forward to seeing you in the next episode! △